Projekt

Daten zum Projekt

HerCoRe - Hermeneutic and Computer based Analysis of Reliability, Consistency and Vagueness in Historical Texts (illustrated through two main historical works of Dimitrie Cantemir)

Zur Projekt-Website

Initiative: "Mixed Methods" in den Geisteswissenschaften?
Ausschreibung: Projekte
Bewilligung: 07.12.2016
Laufzeit: 3 Jahre

Projektinformationen

Dimitrie Cantemir was one of the most prominent figures at the end of XVIIth and beginning of the XVIIIth century in the cultural space of Central Eastern Europe. His works about the history of the Ottoman Empire and the Description of Moldavia were translated in English, German and French and remained capital works until the end of XIXth century. Cantemir's books are partially testimonies of things, events and places he experienced himself. This brings a plus of subjectivism in his writings which results in a scientific discussion about the validity of his historical style. Digital Humanities nowadays tend to use huge corpora ("big data") to achieve reliable results with computer-based technologies. However, behind all interpretations, such as reliability discussions, stands a hermeneutic approach, which is always qualitative in nature. Such research can be backed up by quantitative descriptions of the material. The scientific use of annotations is usually a positive ascription of features, such as "is reliable" or "is not reliable" and a statistics of the corresponding feature. This kind of approach ignores a fundamental aspect of the data, the vagueness of many assertions and thus the drawbacks of such crisp choice "is/is not". The project aims at investigating to which extent assertions found in Cantemir's original texts (in Latin) or in the translations in German and Romanian are: (a) consistent within the same text and across the originals, (b) reliable with respect to author's annotations or the annotations of further translators; (c) consistent and reliable across different language versions. The result of the project will be on the computer science side a prototype tool for computer-based hermeneutic reliability research in historical texts. On the humanistic side the project will deliver a reinterpretation of the hermeneutic cycle given external knowledge, the qualitative analysis performed by historians with the help of the computer based approach, and a comparative report.

Projektbeteiligte

  • Prof. Dr. Thomas Eich

    Universität Hamburg
    Fakultät für Geisteswissenschaften
    Asien-Afrika-Institut
    Hamburg

  • Dr. Anca Dinu, Ph.D.

    University of Bucharest
    Faculty of Foreign Languages and Literatures
    Modern Languages Department
    Bucharest
    Rumänien

  • Dr. Cristina Vertan

    Universität Hamburg
    Informatik
    Hamburger Informatik Technologie-Center e.V
    Hamburg

Open Access-Publikationen